This Steakhouse Has Aged as Well as, Well, Its Steaks - January 2007
"Abel Conklin's was reviewed in this newspaper
20 years ago; it was my first column, on Jan. 4, 1987. Both restaurant
and reviewer have seen myriad changes in Long Island dining in
the ensuing years; restaurants, like everything else, are subject
to trends. . ."
North Shore Dining - May, 2003
". . . Abel Conklin's has made its mark as a bastion
of fine dining."
Zagats 2001/2002 Long Island Restaurants
". . . loyalists swear the 'superb' 'porterhouse
rivals all others'. . . "
Great Restaurants of Long Island, 2002 Edition
"Beautiful oak paneling with mahogany accent the elegant setting of this warm and inviting restaurant in the historic house built by Abel Conklin in 1841"
Newsday
"The appeal of Abel Conklin's, though, is that you don't have to order a big steak to dine well... Given the current economy, it's nice to see a formal steakhouse redefined as a place where one can choose between a 'serious steak' and a casual burger or sandwich and, regardless of which you choose, still balance the family budget.
"
Total Magazine
"... the menu offers a splendid selection of prime meats and seafood."
New York Times - Nov. 18, 2001
"We gave thumbs up to the prime, aged porterhouse, the tender filet mignon and the tasty marinated rib eye."
New York Times - Jan. 4, 1987
"The service, by attractive young people, is efficient and attentive. The owners seem to be on the premises at all times, and their concern is apparent."